Ulysse Nardin Marine Diver "Black Sea" extreme field test

Jun 30, 2012,10:48 AM
 



Testing the rubber-coated
Ulysse Nardin Marine Diver "Black Sea" in the field

by Marcus Hanke




“We need more shovels!” - “And bring another two sand boards!” - “Quick, it could tumble down!” Frantically I was digging away the sand from under the hillside wheels with my spade. The truck was stuck in a critically inclined position, around it were several people, armed with shovels, sand boards and good advice, trying to mitigate the situation, and to get the truck upright again. A steep slope dropped off to the immediate right of the stuck vehicle, far down the outlines of the huge excavator eating through the meter-thick, black layer of coal were discernible.





The driver of the green Bremach T-Rex camper truck had tried to climb uphill, but lost impetus when he had to break through a sand wall and immediately turned left onto the steep slope thereafter. Another Bremach with a powerful hydraulic winch was already in position at the top of the sandy hill, but we had to stabilize the unlucky truck first; otherwise, the first pull of the cable would make it turn over, probably sending it tumbling down the slope. Together with some other group members, I removed sand under the uphill wheels, so the vehicle would straighten up a bit, while others installed the steel sand boards under the downhill wheels, to prevent further slipping.





Sand is not heavy, so the work was not hard; but the potentially dangerous situation made us digging faster and faster, the sand was thrown into the air, sometimes straight into the face of another worker ...



Less than half an hour later, the truck was ready to be salvaged. What followed was unspectacular: pulled by the strong cable, and assisted by its own four-wheel drive, the stranded T-Rex quickly moved uphill and disappeared behind the top edge of the slope. To us remained the work to collect our shovels and boards and follow.

Several weeks earlier: A discussion on current all-black Marine Diver variants here in our PuristSPro forum brought forward the question whether the rubber-coating of the most current models would be durable enough to stand the test of time. I had to admit that I had no experience in this matter. While rubber coating on various watch components, like bezels, pushers and bracelets are common since several years already, a complete cover of all watchcase parts, including those with very delicate surface structures and edges, like the milled rotating bezels of Ulysse Nardin’s Marine Diver watches, was completely new in the the business. It is understandable that potential customers want to be sure about the coat’s ruggedness, since any damage is not just a question of exchanging a small part, but might well necessitate the replacement of the complete case.



Once a year, a small group of offroad-travellers meets somewhere in Germany, to exchange experiences, news and to do some driving. All these travellers own a specific type of compact truck: a Bremach, built by an Italian manufacturer of highly offroad-capable trucks, normally used by municipalities in mountainous regions, fire departments, search and rescue services and armed forces. These trucks are a perfect base for a largely autonomous travelling vehicle, which is why they are popular among people desiring to travel off the popular routes, and remote from touristic infrastructure.





This year, the annual Bremach-meeting had a very special destination: the huge coal-mining area of the Lausitz, south-east of Berlin, along the German-Polish border. Here, the coal is recovered by open-pit mining, while some parts of the mining district, which are exhausted already, are subject of extensive renaturation activities and will soon become a large recreational region. Due to a special permission, we would be able to explore both, the active mining area, and the sites where a “natural” environment is newly made.







That could be an ideal opportunity to subject Ulysse Nardin’s rubber-coated watches to a field test under extreme conditions. A short while later, I had a brand new Marine Diver “Black Sea” in my hands, which Ulysse Nardin thankfully had provided for this test. Of course I grasped the opportunity to make an extensive everyday experience test as well, which will be published at a later time. This report here only deals with the rubber coat’s performance under rather extra-ordinary circumstances.





At first, I had a few reservations, mostly about the watch’s size. Compared with my classic 40mm Marine Diver, the “Black Sea” is very large, with a diameter of more than 45mm. A watch of this size is normally not a good companion in the confined living space of a compact camping truck; I expected it to bang it against edges and furniture very often, maybe even to cause damage on the latter. Regarding the first part, I was right: the noise of a watch colliding with the truck’s interior became rather common, even if it was muted by the rubber. The great thing, however, was that the watch’s shock-absorbing coat reliably prevented any damage of even the more delicate surfaces. Very soon, I moved through the truck without taking specific care to keep the watch away from any obstacles.






The real test was yet to come, though:

“Simon, what’s this on your front axle?”, the CB radio squawked. “What do you mean?” - “Don’t know, looks like ... could it be that your shock absorber was ripped off? Seems to be dangling under the car ...” - “Oh, sh*t! Now that caused the noise ...” - “When?” - “Last week, back in a riverbed in Greece.” - “You mean you drove with a ripped absorber over here from Greece?” - “Well, the driving didn’t become worse, so I thought everything was okay.” - “Anyway, we have to remove it completely now, it could catch a rock and then you are certainly in trouble!” Next, I found myself lying under Simon’s truck, together with him and another driver, and we worked to remove the wrecked shock absorber. Of course, I had forgotten to take off the watch prior to that, so it banged against the various geartrain components many times ...





After three days of driving, shovelling sand, removing rocks from tracks, checking several vehicles’ undersides, releasing and refilling air into large tires, sweating, but also transforming the truck into a sleeping cabin and back into a movable truck again, the poor “Black Sea” appeared to show some traces of this experience. It was dirty everywhere, with sand and coal dust having found its way into even the smallest gaps and edges, forming an unattractive residue.





Back at home, a thorough bath was on order; not only for me, but for the watch as well. To my astonishment, it left the washbowl immaculately. Then came the check with loupes, including an illuminated achromatic loupe with 20x magnification that normally reveals even the tiniest flaws. And what shall I say: there is absolutely no visible damage of the rubber surface!


These pictures were all made AFTER the offroad experience.
The tiny fibres are from the linnen towel I used to swipe the watch after cleaning it in the water. Those textile fabrics tend to stick to the rubber surface. Meanwhile, I found a microfibre cloth to be better, but still not perfect.







This also applies to the ceramic parts on the rubber strap, which had come into close contact with rocks, sharp metal edges, and even abrasive tarmac. What appeared to be scratches, completely vanished after a wipe with a wet towel.





So what is the final result of the Marine Diver “Black Sea” field test? Mission accomplished! - And, by the way: the black-red watch looked really hot there, in the coal mine!





ADDENDUM: In his reply to the original posting of the above article, Ming raised an issue that I had completely overlooked: How does the "Black Sea's" rubber-coated case fare when exposed to chemicals? Of course I am aware that any material can be damaged if the chemical is only aggressive enough, Consequently, I did not consider pouring aqua regia or sulphuric acid over the beautiful "Black Sea".

However, in any well-assorted household, chemicals are handled in everyday life, and whenever the wristwatch is not taken off prior to the respective activities, there is a chance of the watch coming into direct contact with the substances in question. Therefore, I made a small series of experiments with common household chemicals.

Since the "Black Sea" is not my property, and in spite of the fact that my "license to test" was not limited in any way by Ulysse Nardin, I did not want to deliberately damage it. Consequently, I pre-checked every chemical on my own Marine Diver's rubber strap first, and only afterwards I applied it to the rubber-clad underside of the "Black Sea". Every chemical was allowed to stay on the rubber for 60 seconds, before it was thoroughly washed off with clear water.

So here are the results of this additional test:

* common drain pipe cleaner:                no effect
* liquid all-purpose cleaner:                   no effect        
* descaling agent:                                  no effect
* acetic acid (vinegar essence), 25%:    no effect
* hydrochloric acid (HCl), 33%:              no effect
* native olive oil, cold-pressed:              no effect

In Austria, an oil pressed from pumpkin seed is highly popular. It tastes very nuttily, and is valuable and healthy. However, it causes green spots on every material it comes in contact with, washing is absolutely futile. I assume that the "Red Sea" case would get an interesting tint from that oil, and doubt it could be removed again. Therefore, I decided to skip that "test", also, because this kind of mean oil is barely in use outside of Austria.

Finally, just to answer Ming's above-mentioned question:

* gasoline, unleaded: no effect
* Diesel fuel:               no effect

To sum up, the rubber-coated casework of the UN Marine Diver "Black Sea" has proven to be absolutely suited for everyday life's challenges, and even to several more.

Regards,
Marcus





Copyright June 2012 - Marcus Hanke & PuristSPro.com - all rights reserved

PuristSPro Homepage

Comments, suggestions, and corrections to this article are welcome.



  This message has been edited by Marcus Hanke on 2012-07-20 06:47:57




  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

re: extreme

 
 By: DRMW : June 30th, 2012-11:03
Cool report, very interesting to see it out in the field. Did you try to bash into something or drop it to see how durable the coating is? Did you expose the UN Red Sea to any oils, brake fluid or gasoline? =MW

Define "bash" ....

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : June 30th, 2012-11:15
I did not deliberately expose it to specifically harsh treatment, if you mean that. It banged into so many hard things since I received it, that I do not consider it necessary to bash it against a steel carrier with force. I also did not try to scratch it... 

I love these live reports and tests.

 
 By: amanico : June 30th, 2012-11:30
It is one thing to claim that a coating can resist to hard contexts and experiences, it is another thing to verify these statements, and here, you proved that this Red Sea is a real toolwatch. Which is fundamental for this kind of watches. The sand and th... 

Oh, for the new Sonata, you would need the ear of a famous director ...

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : July 3rd, 2012-11:26
... so with my compromised hearing capabilities, I am not the right person. One of the directors here at the Salzburg Festival would be the perfect reviewer, but, unfortunately, I am lacking the right contacts. Regards, Marcus

When you'e used to a sound, it is easier to compare the later.

 
 By: amanico : July 3rd, 2012-11:42
I will try to see it in thev flesh, just hoping that I will not have to wait till November and the Salon Des Beles Montres. Best, Marcus. Nicolas

Marcus, you have made countless memorable posts over the years...

 
 By: MichaelC : June 30th, 2012-16:34
And this is now one of my favorites (I'll always rank the debut of the UN160 as the best UN post). I had been wondering specifically about the rubber coating and its durability. Question answered. The unique look at multiple Bremachs is awesome. Certainly... 

CQ, CQ, truck guy to truck guy: Thanks for your compliments! ...

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : July 3rd, 2012-11:24
To be honest, I am dreaming of a camper version of this beast: http://un1.watchprosite.com/img/watchprosite/un1/98/scaled/un1_image.2869998.jpg (c) Mercedes Benz However, it is simply too large for tight old Europe - and most other parts in the world, too...  

Wow, that would be a great option.

 
 By: MichaelC : July 8th, 2012-18:46
Tracie wants a small camper we can pull, but that really limits where you can go. I like your idea much more ;-)

Very soon, I moved through the truck without taking specific care to keep the watch away f

 
 By: MTF : July 1st, 2012-04:53
My Friend, As we are both "of size" and have to mind our blood cholesterol content, I fully understand the dance you have to do with 2 adults and 2 large hounds in a small Italian truck. :-) It's good to know that you can swerve with alacrity wearing the ... 

You know me so well, dear Melvyn ....

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : July 1st, 2012-07:42
... and - just in the most unlikely of cases that you forgot my astonishing abilities - I'd like to recommend to your valued memory how I move with the legerity of a gazelle: Just add the watch, now ... Best regards, Marcus ...  

Separated at birth (LOL)

 
 By: MTF : July 1st, 2012-10:05
Dear Marcus, I should not have been surprised but the illustration of the 2nd most famous pachyderm to serve as an erstwhile reminder of your terpsichorean ability was superfluous, as that was EXACTLY the image I had flitting around in my mind's eye, like... 

ADDENDUM: The rubber-coated case and chemicals

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : July 1st, 2012-05:14
In his reply further up, Ming raised an issue that I had completely overlooked: How does the "Red Sea's" rubber-coated case fare when exposed to chemicals? Of course I am aware that any material can be damaged if the chemical is only aggressive enough, Co... 

DEET

 
 By: BDLJ : July 1st, 2012-19:20
Good test, Marcus. As DRMW enquired, It'd be interesting to find out what composition the rubber is. One recommendation, no matter what the composition is, I'd recommend keeping ANY watch with plastic or rubber components away from anything containing Tol... 

Not in my case, though ...

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : July 2nd, 2012-00:02
When walking the dogs on the river banks in summer, the mosquitoes try to eat me alive. I found DEET to be the only effective repellent, so I am using a gel containing 30% of DEET since some years, very often together with rubber-strapped watches. Until n... 

If you're washing them...

 
 By: BDLJ : July 2nd, 2012-17:16
...that will avoid any issues. As you wrote, time and concentration are the key. I've split dive band where I hadn't cleaned out the grooves (mind you, it was after weeks of wearing insect repellent everyday) and melted plenty of headphone cord coverings.... 

Marcus, thanks for your amazing report.

 
 By: stere : July 2nd, 2012-01:47
but it's quite hard for me to understand that you had fun in such a moon area, full of sand, dust and dirt and hard work all the time :-) Vielen Dank! stere

Well, "fun" is something highly subjective ....

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : July 3rd, 2012-11:05
... others claim to have fun in a crowded, loud and dark discotheque, I do so in a moonlike landscape. It's good that we all are so different! Regards, Marcus

Wow, another good one from herr doktor...

 
 By: Echi : July 2nd, 2012-03:33
Did i say that right? Anyway, one good way to clean that piece is to use a blower (what we use to clean out dust from lenses and sensors) to take out the excess water from your watch after you wash it. Then probably just use microfibre for the glass. Than... 

Yes, will try a hairdryer ...

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : July 3rd, 2012-11:07
... but in fact, there is not much sense to it. With maked eye, you won't see the thiny fibres sticking on the rubber. It is only an issue for the high-res macro photography, but not in everyday experience. Wash, wipe, c'est ca! Regards, Marcus

Wonderful report Marcus!

 
 By: AnthonyTsai : July 2nd, 2012-19:44
One quick question - is the rubber coating on thiis UN Marine Diver a proprietary rubber coating? Or is it just a standard rubber coating that all the watch brands use such as IWC & JLC which have rubber coated watches? I'm a big fan of your real worl... 

Thank you so much, dear Anthony!

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : July 3rd, 2012-11:10
I will ask about the rubber issue. However, I suspect that it is done by the case manufacturer, that might be the same for several high-class brands. In practice, I am positive that the other timepieces made by IWC, AP etc. will not perform differently. I... 

Another excellent review Marcus!

 
 By: jmpTT : July 3rd, 2012-22:04
I've always found your posts, especially your reviews to be quite informative. While I was not necessarily interested in the UN Marine Diver, I was quite curious to find out whether the rubber coating would perform well in the field. The underlying narrit... 

Thank you, also for your interest in the pumpkin seed oil ...

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : July 4th, 2012-03:47
... here is some more info: http://www.steirisches-kuerbiskernoel-gga.at/index.php?lang=en It is really very tasty! Best regards, Marcus

Stupid, stupid me: It is called the "Black Sea"!!

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : July 6th, 2012-09:45
I don't believe it: All the time I used a wrong designation of the watch! Due to its bright red markers and hands, I simply assumed it was called "Red Sea", in spite of having used the correct name back in 2011 myself .... oh my, there are so many seas an...  

LOL, we missed it too...

 
 By: MichaelC : July 8th, 2012-18:45
You are in the clear!